Tuesday, October 13, 2009

Turning Confrontation into Effective Communication

Most people hate confrontations, especially at work. Unfortunately, being a manager often means telling people things they don’t want to hear, leading to responses from unpleasant to unbelievable. However, you can deal with tough talks and turn them into meaningful communication if you understand the goal, choose an effective strategy, and stick to your plan.

Understand the Goal

Every party in a conversation has a goal. If you clearly understand your goal and consider the possible goals of others, you can choose an effective strategy for getting what you want while giving us much as possible to the other parties involved.

For example, when you give John a poor review, your goal might be his commitment to a plan for improving his performance. John is probably after praise and a raise. Understanding this will help you to choose an effective strategy that achieves your goal while holding out the promise of warm fuzzies and cold cash in the future.

Choose an Effective Strategy

An effective strategy is one that focuses on actions and outcomes. In the example above, you want John to commit to a plan of action with the eventual outcome of improving his performance. He wants a good review and more money.

In practical terms, a good strategy would be to:

  1. State up front that the John’s performance did not meet expectations
  2. Reassure him that the key to future success can be found in his review
  3. Offer another review in 30 days as an incentive for executing an action plan
  4. Proceed with the review and work with John to develop an action plan
  5. Finish with both of you signing the mutually agreed upon action plan
It would benefit you to draft an action plan in advance and use it as a guide for your discussion. The final plan may differ, but you’ll have the framework done.

Stick to the Plan


This is the key to success. When a conversation turns ugly, remind yourself of the goal and your strategy for achieving it. Do not be led astray and do not react out of ego or emotion instead of reason. If John starts saying that Jane’s performance is even worse then his, don’t take it personally and get angry, just gently but firmly remind him that this is his review, not Jane’s, and get back to the matter at hand, finding a way to improve his performance.

If John remains uncooperative, continue bringing him back to the facts: his performance is not meeting expectations and if he wants to earn a good review and secure a raise he needs to improve it. The best way to improve his performance is to work with you to create and implement an action plan.

It’s never easy dealing with difficult conversations, but if you understand the goal, choose an effective strategy, and stick to your plan, your can turn a potential battle of egos into meaningful communication.